AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC (AFG)

Latest Insider Confidence Score

2026Q1

44.5
Bearish

Company insider confidence (by quarter)

2014Q1 2026Q1

Largest shareholders

Insider Role (last 12 mo) Shares held Filed at
Lindner S Craig CEO 3,228,699.97 Mar 22, 2021
American Financial Group Inc 10% Owner 2,572,111 Dec 8, 2016
Lindner Carl H III CEO 2,075,114 Feb 3, 2021
Thompson David Lawrence Jr President 769,615.84 Feb 10, 2022
Lindner Stephen Craig Jr Director 336,634 Dec 5, 2025

Recent buy/sell transactions

Exec date Filing date Insider Role Signal Confidence Shares % of shares Under plan? Amount (USD)
Feb 26, 2026 Mar 2, 2026 LINDNER CARL H III CEO Neutral 60.0 +11,294 0.21% ✗ -
Feb 26, 2026 Mar 2, 2026 Gillis Michelle A President Neutral 85.0 +3,012 5.30% ✗ -
Feb 26, 2026 Mar 2, 2026 Hertzman Brian S. CFO Sell 90.0 +1,500 9.12% ✗ $222.3K
Feb 26, 2026 Mar 2, 2026 Thompson David Lawrence Jr President Neutral 67.5 +4,706 0.76% ✗ -
Feb 26, 2026 Mar 2, 2026 Weiss Mark A Sr. VP & General Counsel Neutral 90.0 +3,012 16.57% ✗ -
Feb 26, 2026 Mar 2, 2026 LINDNER S CRAIG CEO Neutral 60.0 +11,294 0.26% ✗ -
Feb 26, 2026 Mar 2, 2026 Lindner Stephen Craig Jr Director Neutral 67.5 +3,389 0.86% ✗ -
Feb 26, 2026 Mar 2, 2026 BERDING JOHN B President Neutral 85.0 +8,847 6.87% ✗ -
Feb 23, 2026 Feb 24, 2026 LINDNER CARL H III CEO Sell 45.0 -3,810 -0.07% ✗ $494.7K
Feb 23, 2026 Feb 24, 2026 LINDNER S CRAIG CEO Sell 45.0 -3,300 -0.08% ✗ $428.5K
Feb 23, 2026 Feb 24, 2026 Lindner Stephen Craig Jr Director Sell 47.5 -761 -0.19% ✗ $98.8K
Feb 23, 2026 Feb 24, 2026 Thompson David Lawrence Jr President Sell 47.5 -1,098 -0.18% ✗ $142.6K
Feb 23, 2026 Feb 24, 2026 BERDING JOHN B President Sell 20.0 -2,050 -1.57% ✗ $266.2K
Feb 23, 2026 Feb 24, 2026 Gillis Michelle A President Sell 22.5 -730 -1.27% ✗ $94.8K
Feb 23, 2026 Feb 24, 2026 Weiss Mark A Sr. VP & General Counsel Sell 22.5 -658 -3.49% ✗ $85.4K
Feb 22, 2026 Feb 24, 2026 Hertzman Brian S. CFO Sell 22.5 -727 -4.23% ✗ $94.4K
Feb 5, 2026 BERDING JOHN B President Neutral 52.5 - 0.00% ✗ -
Feb 5, 2026 LINDNER S CRAIG CEO Neutral 52.5 - 0.00% ✗ -
Feb 5, 2026 Hertzman Brian S. CFO Neutral 52.5 - 0.00% ✗ -
Dec 19, 2025 Feb 5, 2026 JOSEPH GREGORY G Director Neutral 67.5 +973 0.78% ✗ -
Jan 28, 2026 Jan 29, 2026 Lindner Stephen Craig Jr Director Neutral 60.0 +864 0.22% ✗ -
Dec 29, 2025 Dec 30, 2025 Gillis Michelle A President Neutral 37.5 -542 -0.93% ✗ -
Dec 16, 2025 Dec 22, 2025 LINDNER CARL H III CEO Neutral 52.5 -403 -0.01% ✗ -
Dec 18, 2025 Dec 22, 2025 Lindner Stephen Craig Jr Director Neutral 52.5 -44 -0.01% ✗ -
Dec 18, 2025 Dec 22, 2025 Thompson David Lawrence Jr President Neutral 52.5 -828 -0.13% ✗ -
Dec 15, 2025 Dec 16, 2025 LINDNER S CRAIG CEO Neutral 52.5 -3,342 -0.08% ✗ -
Dec 15, 2025 Dec 16, 2025 Lindner Stephen Craig Jr Director Neutral 60.0 +1,380 0.36% ✗ -
Dec 9, 2025 Dec 11, 2025 LINDNER CARL H III CEO Neutral 37.5 -37,424 -0.68% ✗ -
Dec 3, 2025 Dec 5, 2025 Lindner Stephen Craig Jr Director Neutral 52.5 - 0.00% ✗ -
Nov 7, 2025 Nov 10, 2025 Hertzman Brian S. CFO Sell 20.0 -1,777 -9.48% ✗ $253.2K
Jun 28, 2024 Jun 28, 2024 Murray Amy Y Director Buy 95.0 +1,200 54.84% ✗ $150.2K
Jun 3, 2024 Jun 4, 2024 Newport Roger K Director Neutral 90.0 +1,279 127.90% ✗ -
Jun 3, 2024 Jun 4, 2024 Evans James E Director Neutral 77.5 +1,279 1.15% ✗ -
Jun 3, 2024 Jun 4, 2024 Nwankwo Evans N Director Neutral 90.0 +1,279 34.71% ✗ -
Jun 3, 2024 Jun 4, 2024 Murray Amy Y Director Neutral 90.0 +1,279 140.70% ✗ -
Jun 3, 2024 Jun 4, 2024 VON LEHMAN JOHN I Director Neutral 90.0 +1,279 10.36% ✗ -
Jun 3, 2024 Jun 4, 2024 VERITY WILLIAM W Director Neutral 90.0 +1,279 12.23% ✗ -
Jun 3, 2024 Jun 4, 2024 JOSEPH GREGORY G Director Neutral 77.5 +1,279 1.08% ✗ -
Jun 3, 2024 Jun 4, 2024 Martin Mary Beth Director Neutral 90.0 +1,279 16.98% ✗ -
Apr 25, 2024 Apr 29, 2024 JOSEPH GREGORY G Director Neutral 67.5 +840 0.72% ✗ -
Mar 22, 2024 Mar 25, 2024 LINDNER CARL H III CEO Neutral 52.5 -23 0.00% ✗ -
Mar 12, 2024 Mar 13, 2024 Evans James E Director Sell 20.0 -2,274 -2.00% ✗ $292.5K
Dec 18, 2023 Mar 7, 2024 LINDNER CARL H III CEO Neutral 27.5 -50,894 -1.10% ✗ -
Mar 1, 2024 Mar 4, 2024 Gillis Michelle A President Sell 20.0 -2,053 -3.81% ✗ $260.3K
Mar 1, 2024 Newport Roger K Director Neutral 52.5 - 0.00% ✗ -
Feb 27, 2024 Feb 28, 2024 Thompson David Lawrence Jr President Neutral 67.5 +4,753 0.92% ✗ -
Feb 27, 2024 Feb 28, 2024 BERDING JOHN B President Neutral 85.0 +8,912 8.42% ✗ -
Feb 27, 2024 Feb 28, 2024 Hertzman Brian S. CFO Sell 95.0 +2,102 15.12% ✗ $135.5K
Feb 27, 2024 Feb 28, 2024 LINDNER S CRAIG CEO Neutral 60.0 +11,882 0.28% ✗ -
Feb 27, 2024 Feb 28, 2024 Weiss Mark A Sr. VP & General Counsel Sell 90.0 +511 3.11% ✗ $317.7K
Feb 27, 2024 Feb 28, 2024 Gillis Michelle A President Neutral 85.0 +3,011 5.92% ✗ -
Feb 27, 2024 Feb 28, 2024 LINDNER CARL H III CEO Neutral 60.0 +11,882 0.26% ✗ -
Feb 25, 2024 Feb 27, 2024 Weiss Mark A Sr. VP & General Counsel Sell 22.5 -784 -4.55% ✗ $99.3K
Feb 25, 2024 Feb 27, 2024 BERDING JOHN B President Sell 20.0 -3,076 -2.82% ✗ $389.5K
Feb 25, 2024 Feb 27, 2024 LINDNER CARL H III CEO Sell 45.0 -6,392 -0.14% ✗ $809.4K
Feb 25, 2024 Feb 27, 2024 LINDNER S CRAIG CEO Sell 45.0 -6,062 -0.14% ✗ $767.6K
Feb 25, 2024 Feb 27, 2024 Thompson David Lawrence Jr President Sell 47.5 -796 -0.15% ✗ $100.8K
Feb 25, 2024 Feb 27, 2024 Hertzman Brian S. CFO Sell 22.5 -468 -3.26% ✗ $59.3K
Feb 25, 2024 Feb 27, 2024 Gillis Michelle A President Sell 22.5 -1,017 -1.96% ✗ $128.8K
Feb 22, 2024 Feb 22, 2024 VON LEHMAN JOHN I Director Sell 22.5 -1,773 -12.56% ✗ $222.5K
Feb 14, 2024 Feb 15, 2024 Thompson David Lawrence Jr President Neutral 90.0 +100,000 23.83% ✗ -
Feb 14, 2024 Feb 15, 2024 LINDNER CARL H III CEO Neutral 27.5 -400,000 -7.95% ✗ -
Feb 9, 2024 Hertzman Brian S. CFO Neutral 52.5 - 0.00% ✗ -
Jan 16, 2024 Feb 9, 2024 LINDNER S CRAIG CEO Neutral 47.5 +304 0.01% ✗ -
Feb 9, 2024 BERDING JOHN B President Neutral 52.5 - 0.00% ✗ -
Feb 8, 2024 Feb 9, 2024 Gillis Michelle A President Sell 20.0 -5,176 -9.62% ✗ $626.3K
Dec 28, 2023 Jan 2, 2024 JOSEPH GREGORY G Director Neutral 55.0 +210 0.18% ✗ -
Dec 27, 2023 Dec 28, 2023 Murray Amy Y Director Sell 22.5 -850 -48.32% ✗ $100.4K
Dec 27, 2023 Dec 28, 2023 Gillis Michelle A President Neutral 27.5 -1,260 -2.53% ✗ -
Dec 20, 2023 Dec 20, 2023 VERITY WILLIAM W Director Sell 20.0 -2,274 -17.86% ✗ $273.5K
Dec 14, 2023 Dec 18, 2023 Thompson David Lawrence Jr President Neutral 52.5 -840 -0.20% ✗ -
Dec 15, 2023 Dec 18, 2023 Murray Amy Y Director Sell 26.3 -415 -19.09% ✗ $49.4K
Dec 15, 2023 Dec 18, 2023 LINDNER S CRAIG CEO Neutral 45.0 -11,777 -0.28% ✗ -
Nov 13, 2023 Nov 15, 2023 BERDING JOHN B President Buy 82.5 +1,170 1.09% ✗ $126.3K
Sep 8, 2023 Sep 12, 2023 BERDING JOHN B President Buy 92.5 +8,829 6.49% ✗ $966.2K
Feb 6, 2023 Aug 8, 2023 LINDNER S CRAIG CEO Buy 95.0 +275,730 6.93% ✗ $4M
Aug 4, 2023 Aug 8, 2023 BERDING JOHN B President Buy 92.5 +5,307 5.70% ✗ $590.8K
Jun 26, 2023 Jun 28, 2023 BERDING JOHN B President Neutral 90.0 +17,114 22.88% ✗ -
Jun 12, 2023 Jun 13, 2023 JACOBS TERRY S Director Sell 22.5 -761 -9.21% ✗ $88.2K
Jun 8, 2023 Jun 8, 2023 VON LEHMAN JOHN I Director Sell 22.5 -1,479 -9.48% ✗ $173.6K
Jun 1, 2023 Jun 2, 2023 VERITY WILLIAM W Director Neutral 90.0 +1,411 12.46% ✗ -
Jun 1, 2023 Jun 2, 2023 Murray Amy Y Director Neutral 90.0 +1,411 184.93% ✗ -
Jun 1, 2023 Jun 2, 2023 Evans James E Director Neutral 77.5 +1,411 1.25% ✗ -
Jun 1, 2023 Jun 2, 2023 VON LEHMAN JOHN I Director Neutral 85.0 +1,411 9.95% ✗ -
Jun 1, 2023 Jun 2, 2023 JACOBS TERRY S Director Neutral 90.0 +1,411 20.60% ✗ -
Jun 1, 2023 Jun 2, 2023 Martin Mary Beth Director Neutral 90.0 +1,411 23.05% ✗ -
Jun 1, 2023 Jun 2, 2023 JOSEPH GREGORY G Director Neutral 77.5 +1,411 1.22% ✗ -
Jun 1, 2023 Jun 2, 2023 Nwankwo Evans N Director Neutral 90.0 +1,411 62.05% ✗ -
May 19, 2023 May 22, 2023 Peraino Vito C Senior VP & Executive Counsel Neutral 27.5 -4,275 -4.08% ✗ -
Feb 6, 2023 Mar 21, 2023 LINDNER CARL H III CEO Neutral 85.0 +239,875 5.00% ✗ -
Mar 13, 2023 Mar 15, 2023 JOSEPH GREGORY G Director Neutral 67.5 +980 0.86% ✗ -
Mar 2, 2023 Mar 2, 2023 Hertzman Brian S. CFO Sell 22.5 -1,080 -7.09% ✗ $146K
Feb 26, 2023 Feb 28, 2023 Thompson David Lawrence Jr President Sell 47.5 -784 -0.19% ✗ $103K
Feb 26, 2023 Feb 28, 2023 LINDNER S CRAIG CEO Sell 45.0 -4,843 -0.12% ✗ $636.2K
Feb 2, 2023 Feb 28, 2023 Gillis Michelle A President Sell 22.5 -978 -1.92% ✗ $128.5K
Feb 26, 2023 Feb 28, 2023 Weiss Mark A Senior VP & General Counsel Sell 22.5 -513 -2.89% ✗ $67.4K
Feb 26, 2023 Feb 28, 2023 BERDING JOHN B President Sell 20.0 -3,747 -4.77% ✗ $492.2K
Feb 26, 2023 Feb 28, 2023 Peraino Vito C Senior VP & Executive Counsel Sell 22.5 -1,813 -1.70% ✗ $238.2K
Feb 2, 2023 Feb 28, 2023 Hertzman Brian S. CFO Sell 22.5 -485 -3.09% ✗ $63.7K
Feb 26, 2023 Feb 28, 2023 LINDNER CARL H III CEO Sell 45.0 -5,644 -0.12% ✗ $741.4K